Last Updated on April 27, 2021
This is a guest post by Claire.
This post contains affiliate links.
One surprising find at Aldi that has become a repeat buy for me is protein powder. Even with Amazon being a factor, I haven’t found a better deal for the price, flavor, and macronutrients.
Millville’s Elevation Protein Powder can be bought in vanilla or chocolate flavors. I have bought the chocolate before and enjoyed it, but I usually buy the vanilla since I get bored easily and like to experiment with adding different ingredients to my shake.
This Regular Buy is $15.39 on Instacart and may be cheaper in-store. In my location, I think this is around $13.99. The container is 2 pounds and contains about 18 servings.
Each serving contains 170 calories, 2.5 grams of fat, 80mg of cholesterol, 8 grams of carbs, 2 grams of sugar, 30 grams of protein, 160mg of calcium, 85mg of sodium, 250mg of potassium, and 4.5 grams of a creatine-amino acid blend.
The ingredients consist of whey protein concentrate, whey protein isolate, maltodextrin, cellulose gum, soy lecithin, natural and artificial flavors, sugar, dextrose, modified food starch, acesulfame potassium, sucralose, propylene glycol, cornstarch, tricalcium phosphate, and silicon dioxide. It contains milk and soy and is manufactured in a facility that also processes wheat and egg.
I’ll start with the price. I’ve bought protein powders for around this price point before on Amazon, but they were usually running large promotions or were just gross. They typically run anywhere from $15-$25. If you shop in supplement or fitness shops, those prices easily creep over $30. I will say that most other protein powders do come with more servings than 18. Even factoring that in however, Aldi’s choice is very competitive.
Now consider the cost with the macronutrients. If you’re consuming protein shakes on a regular basis, it’s a fair bet that you’re interested in how these compare to other brands. While all protein powders will increase your protein levels, the goal (unless you’re trying to bulk) is typically to find a powder that increases your protein as much as possible without adding too many calories.
Millville’s Elevation Vanilla Protein Powder contains 170 calories per serving and 30 grams of protein. That’s 5.7 calories per every gram of protein. A comparable brand — indeed it’s listed on Millville’s packaging as being similar — is Body Fortress. Their vanilla Super Advanced Whey Protein is 190 calories per serving and 30 grams of protein, or 6.3 calories per gram of protein.
Not only does Millville’s calorie-to-protein ratio “win,” it’s also a few dollars cheaper.
Finally, the taste of this vanilla protein powder is very similar to that of a milkshake and isn’t chalky like some other brands. While I like it, I would warn that it is very sweet. Given the extensive ingredient list, it’s obvious that this is not a natural sweetness, but I enjoy it regardless.
When I’m in a pinch, I can blend the powder with milk or water on its own in the blender or a shaker bottle and still enjoy the taste. Usually however, I try to shoot for more of a milkshake and will throw in fruit or more dessert-like options.
Here’s one recipe I enjoy making:
- 1 serving of the Elevation Vanilla Protein Powder (2 scoops)
- 1 handful of Aldi’s Little Salad Bar pre-packaged Spinach
- 2T of PBfit or 1T of regular peanut butter
- 4-6 ice cubes
- 1 cup of almond milk or water
- ½ banana
- 1 pinch – 2t cinnamon
Blend until smooth and keep adding liquid for desired consistency.
Clearly, I like to add in a lot of extras, but at the end of the day you really just need the powder, liquid, and likely ice.
While I wish that Aldi offered a bit more of an inventory in protein powders, Millville’s Elevation Vanilla Protein Powder is typically my first choice when I want to be cost-conscious without sacrificing taste or protein content. I think the only drawback to some health aficionados would be their less-than-all-natural ingredient list.
Claire Tadokoro works in publishing in New York City. Her writing can be found at www.clairetadokoro.com. She’s on Twitter and Instagram @ClaireTadokoro.
I bought some of the protein + greens when it was in the special buys a few weeks ago. I noticed a huge discrepancy between the size of the canister and the amount of powder that’s actually in there… it’s only about half full. Did you find this as well? (IMO the canister could be way smaller.)
Hi Brenna! When you say the “protein + greens” are you referring to a different, limited edition protein powder? (If so– I’d love to try it) Or do you mean the protein powder referenced in the review along with greens added in?
For the protein powder I reviewed, I completely agree. They could definitely package the powder in a smaller canister, but I still think it comes out to the advertised amount of servings. Oh the age of over-packaging!!
The powder settles over time after packaging. Every powder I have tried has a similar packaging to product ratio 🙂
The vanilla protein powder is never in stock
I’ve enjoyed the vanilla Millville whey protein powder for several years. I’ve seen packaging changes before with no notice of any consistency change, however, the recent package change may be a different thing. Mixing with skim milk doesn’t give the same result anymore. Even with vigorous mixing the product has a cheese curds look when the powder doesn’t blend in. Then I noticed the ingredient list is a bit different. I hate to buy another container to test the results. Is it me or did Aldo / Millville change the formula? I doubt it’s one bad container. Monty
Wow, why would anyone ingest all of those really bad ingredients? Generally, I find Millville products to be a wash of unwanted industrial additives, chemicals, preservatives, etc., and this cocktail is not different. Bottom line: you get what you pay for.
I was wondering the same. I would find an alternative to protein powder rather than consume the chemicals in this. Yikes!