Last Updated on December 7, 2023
EDITOR’S NOTE 1: If you’re looking for a review of the Benner Tea Co. Sugar Cookie Tea, which replaced the seasonal chai in 2023, click here.
EDITOR’S NOTE 2: Most of the comments on this post come from readers trying to find the holiday teas. These teas are an Aldi Find (Special Buy), which means that Aldi only stocks a limited amount in a one-week window during the winter holidays, and once that supply is sold out, it’s gone, probably until next year.
At this point, Aldi doesn’t sell products online if they’re not currently in stock at your local store. So if you can’t find the tea at Aldi, you’ll have to either 1) search for similar teas under different brands at other stores or 2) wait until next year. If you wish Aldi carried this tea more often or you want to let Aldi know what you think, you can contact the grocer here.
While making my way to the checkout line at Aldi recently, I noticed some nontraditional flavored teas for sale. Aldi tends to be very
boring traditional in this department, with mostly English Breakfast Tea and green tea among its Regular Buys, and Aldi occasionally sells some other flavors as Special Buys (ALDI Finds). I drink a cup of tea almost every morning, and I love new and unique flavors, so I end up buying a lot of my tea at other stores.
When Aldi recently carried some new selections as part of its Aldi Finds (Special Buys), I put one of each flavor in my cart.
Let’s take a look at the Special Buy offerings:
Benner Tea Co. Candy Cane Tea
This is a caffeine-free herbal tea that can be served hot or cold. The box contains 20 individually packaged bags. I was most excited about getting this because I love the name-brand Celestial Seasonings Candy Cane Lane tea.
These two teas are not quite the same, though. For comparison’s sake, the Benner Tea Co. Candy Cane tea contains peppermint, cinnamon, spearmint, licorice, roasted carob, natural flavor, and chicory. It has a stronger mint flavor, and I couldn’t taste the other ingredients as much. In comparison, Celestial Seasonings Candy Cane Lane tea contains peppermint, green tea, orange peel, natural mint flavor with other natural flavors, cinnamon, milk thistle, blackberry leaves, roasted carob, roasted chicory, and vanilla bean.
The Celestial Seasonings tea has a dominant peppermint flavor, but I can also readily taste the vanilla and other ingredients; it has a more nuanced flavor. In contrast, Aldi’s Benner Tea Co. Candy Cane tea tastes good, but if you want the classic Candy Cane Lane flavor, you’ll want to go with name-brand Celestial Seasonings. I also think Trader Joe’s Candy Cane tea has a more complex flavor, with peppermint and hints of vanilla.
Benner Tea Co. Cinnamon Spice
This is a solid caffeine-free herbal tea with good cinnamon flavor. It also comes with 20 individually packaged bags and can be served hot or cold.
The ingredients are cinnamon, chamomile, rose hip, rooibos, ginger, natural flavor, lemongrass, peppermint, and orange peel.
Overall, this makes a good, flavorful brew that can be enjoyed during the holidays and year round.
Benner Tea Co. Chai
This caffeinated tea comes with 20 individually packaged bags and, again, can be served hot or cold. It’s advertised as “black tea with exotic spices.”
The ingredients are black tea, ginger, cinnamon, black pepper, cardamom, cloves, and star anise.
I’ve sampled several other name brands of chai from other grocery stores over the years, and this one from Aldi was decent, but the flavor seemed a bit weak compared to other chai. It’s still good considering the low price. This is another brew that can be enjoyed year round and not only during the holidays.
Aldi’s selection of Special Buy Benner Tea Co. holiday teas is solid. The candy cane variety has a nice mint flavor, and the cinnamon spice variety has plenty of cinnamon and good flavor. The chai tea seemed a little weak on flavor but was still decent. They are all good ways to get your daily brew without spending a lot of money, and it’s nice to see Aldi offering some new flavors.